The Future is Engineering

Do Great Engineering Schools Beget Entrepreneurism? by Brent Edwards provides two great links.

How to Kick Silicon Valley’s Butt by Guy Kawasaki:

Focus on educating engineers. The most important thing you can do is establish a world-class school of engineering. Engineering schools beget engineers. Engineers beget ideas. And ideas beget companies. End of discussion.

If I had to point to the single biggest reason for Silicon Valley’s existence, it would be Stanford University—specifically, the School of Engineering. Business schools are not of primary importance because MBAs seldom sit around discussing how to change the world with great products.

Why Startups Condense in America:

You need a great university to seed a silicon valley, and so far there are few outside the US. I asked a handful of American computer science professors which universities in Europe were most admired, and they all basically said “Cambridge” followed by a long pause while they tried to think of others. There don’t seem to be many universities elsewhere that compare with the best in America, at least in technology.

Both essays make many excellent points – read them! They both realize there is no magic bullet. Many factors will determine how successfully an economy can create powerful economic gains. Both focus on the importance of world class engineering education to create something to rival silicon valley. Many countries are investing heavily in science and engineering education in order to secure the long term economic benefits that such investment will lead to.

Few can hope to create a silicon valley. But even if the goal is just to gain economic advantage from their heavy investments in engineering education they would be wise to take heed of the ideas presented by both authors.

More than just graduating more and more engineers is required to gain powerful economic advantages. That is a good first step but today China, India, Korea, Germany, Japan, United Kingdom… should be looking at other things the USA has done right (in addition to investing in engineering education).

The factors in addition to great schools are just as important now as trying to create engineering programs that can compare to Standford, MIT, Purdue, Carnegie Mellon, Berkley, Illinois… That still should be a focus but the progress in that area has been significant now is the time to look to additional areas while continuing to work on improving the schools themselves. And the USA should try to add to the advantages that they have and try to extend the success of places like MIT and Standford to more schools (as many people are trying to do).

27 thoughts on “The Future is Engineering

  1. Pingback: Curious Cat Science and Engineering Blog » Discoveries by Accident

  2. Pingback: Curious Cat Science and Engineering Blog » Science and Engineering in Global Economics

  3. Pingback: Entrepreneurial Engineers

  4. Pingback: Curious Cat Science and Engineering Blog » Engineering a Start-up

  5. Pingback: Educational Institutions Economic Impact

  6. Pingback: USC Innovation Institute Reinventing Itself

  7. Pingback: Curious Cat Science and Engineering Blog » What do Engineers Need To Know?

  8. Pingback: CuriousCat: Education, Entrepreneurship and Immigration

  9. Pingback: CuriousCat: Engineers - Future Prospects

  10. Pingback: CuriousCat: USA Losing Brain Drain Benefits

  11. Pingback: Curious Cat Science and Engineering Blog » Economic Strength Through Technology Leadership

  12. Pingback: CuriousCat: Brain Drain Benefits to the USA Less Than They Could Be

  13. Pingback: CuriousCat: Engineering Innovation in Manufacturing and the Economy

  14. Pingback: Engineering &: Engineering for a Changing World

  15. Narsi

    Useful insights…it sounds absurd that one university can a silicon valley make, but well it is difficult to deny the enormous influence Stanford University (OK, ok, their engineering branch) plays in the shaping of silicon valley

    Thanks again for a good article and those two useful quotes – those of Paul Graham and Guy!

  16. Pingback: Curious Cat Science and Engineering Blog » High School Students in USA, China and India

  17. Pingback: Curious Cat Science and Engineering Blog » China challenges dominance of USA, Europe and Japan

  18. Pingback: Curious Cat Science and Engineering Blog » USA Science Losing Ground

  19. Pingback: Curious Cat Science and Engineering Blog » Lake Superior vs. Silicon Valley Hot Spots

  20. Yasinta

    engineering improves technology –> productivity increase –> output increase with lesser input –> things become cheaper –> low inflation –> low interest rate –> boost economy.

  21. Pingback: Curious Cat Science and Engineering Blog » Cuts for British Science

  22. Kalen

    I agree. I attended both an engineering program and an MBA and the latter was a waste as an entrepreneur. Engineers are actually more successful entrepreneurs because they are encouraged to create change while MBAs have people maintain the status quo. Of course, MBAs tell you the importance of being original and creating change, but actively discourage it in practice.

  23. Anonymous

    Advances in Science and technology are important but what is more important are the people who turn the raw data of scientific research into actual services or products. There are so many innovative opportunities out there that haven’t even been tapped into. I am further reminded of Peter Drucker when he analyzed the different types of innovative opportunities and found that scientific was the most risky and had the longest lag time from conception to market ready.

  24. Pingback: Residence Pass for Talented Expats | Living in Malaysia

  25. Anonymous

    Fascinating reading but surely there’s no real doubt that engineering schools lead to entrepreneurial activity. The example of Cambridge in England is given as a great university outside of America and sure enough the area around Cambridge is a hot bed of startups. It’ll be interesting to see what happens in the coming years around Chinese universities.

  26. Pingback: USA Proposes Rule to Welcome International Entrepreneurs | Freelance Lifestyle, Finance and Entrepreneurship Blog

Comments are closed.